|
Wall Street Journal Health
Aches & Claims/ By
Robert J. Davis
Can Acupuncture Punch Up Your Appearance?
While evidence mounts that acupuncture
can relieve nausea and pain associated with a variety of conditions,
some are trying it for a different reason: to get rid of wrinkles.
Some enthusiast of acupuncture
facials, who reportedly include models and Hollywood celebrities,
see the treatment as an alternative to Botox and face-lifts.
Facial rejuvenation acupuncture, as the
practice sometimes is called, involves placing tiny needles along
wrinkles and frown lines. The needles are smaller and thinner than
normal acupuncture needles. In some cases, needles also are inserted
into other parts of the body, such as the ankles, hands or legs.
The number and placement of needles vary according to the severity
of wrinkles and the practitioner's preference.
Generally, people receive 10 to 15 treatments
(typically one or two a week lasting 30-60 minutes), with monthly
visits after that to maintain the effects. Practitioner's say results
begin to appear after a few sessions and become more noticeable
as treatment progresses. The cost, which isn't covered by insurance,
is $60 to $150 for a single session.
Proponents say the treatment increases blood
flow and the production of collagen (which gives the skin it's elasticity,
improving complexion and reducing lines, sagging and bags under
the eyes. Some practitioners say it can take as much as 15 years
off a person's appearance.
Such claims are unproven, however, because
there is virtually no research on facial acupuncture. One frequently
cited study concluded that a course of 20 treatments produced a
"marked" effect in 90% of people. But the research consisted
simply of one practitioner's case reports and no comparison group,
making the findings preliminary at best.
While many doctors scoff at the idea of
using acupuncture for cosmetic reasons, some dermatologists say
it is possible the treatment may have a very short-term, subtle
effect in people under age 50, possibly by causing facial muscles
to contract. But they say it is no substitute for a face-lift, a
point with which even many proponents of acupuncture facials agree.
If done properly, acupuncture is considered
safe. While most don't find needles in the face to be painful, some
who are especially sensitive experience discomfort. The treatment
isn't recommended for pregnant women and people who are on blood
thinning medicines.
To find a qualified acupuncturist, check
with the National Certified Commission for Acupuncture and Oriental
Medicine (www.nccaom.org). Find out about the practitioner's experience
with and training in facial rejuvenation.
And beware of anyone who promises too much.
With reporting by John M. Gunn
|